ROBOTICS ROUNDTABLE: Easing the pain

0 30

Panelists:

ADAM COLE, Director of Customer Strategy, Storage Solutions

ART ELDRED, Senior Vice President, Sales & Software, Attabotics

OANA JINGA, Chief Commercial & Product Officer, Dexory

COLIN MCALEENAN, Vice President of Marketing and Business Development, Hai Robotics Americas

MICHAEL WALTERS, Sales Director, Swisslog Americas

Q: WHAT ARE THE BIGGEST FACTORS INFLUENCING CURRENT AUTOMATION DECISIONS?

Oana Jinga – Dexory: Businesses are increasingly looking for automation that delivers measurable value quickly without requiring major changes to existing infrastructure. In warehousing, labor availability, cost pressures, and the need for greater operational resilience remain important drivers, but access to accurate, real-time data is becoming just as critical. Companies increasingly want automation that not only performs a task but also gives them continuous insight into what is happening across their operations so they can identify issues earlier and make faster, better-informed decisions.

Michael Walters – Swisslog: Labor availability, rising operational costs, and space constraints remain at the center of most automation decisions. Companies are seeking to reduce their dependence on difficult-to-source labor while increasing capacity within their existing footprint.

At the same time, companies are becoming more proactive and informed in how they approach automation. They are looking to build resiliency and flexibility into their operations to scale more easily and respond to future business volatility. Automation is increasingly viewed not just as a solution to a current problem but also as a strategic platform for long-term growth and operational stability.

Adam Cole – Storage Solutions: Safety, security, storage capacity, throughput, labor requirements, and quality are all drivers of automation decisions, but the amount of influence each one has depends on the specific needs of the company. For example, a company may not have throughput challenges, but it may be running out of space. In this case, automation that densifies storage would be the most valuable. Another organization may have plenty of storage but struggles to meet demand, making throughput the most important metric.

Since every operation is unique, decision-makers must be armed with a thorough understanding of their operations and business challenges, which is why working with an expert partner is so important. Automation system providers have the expertise to guide decision-makers through an analysis of their business to ensure each factor is weighted appropriately.

Colin McAleenan – Hai: Uncertainty. Uncertainty in operational consistency, uncertainty in forecasting demand, uncertainty with inflation, uncertainty in the cost of capital, uncertainty in geopolitical stability, uncertainty in supply chain resilience. The last two years have been turbulent for those looking to invest in warehouse automation, but not from the standpoint of holding off investing. In fact, quite the opposite. Uncertainty is now the world order under which we operate—so customers have largely been desensitized, which ironically, has given them the motivation to proceed, cautiously but steadily, with investing in automation because they must continue toward their strategic North Star—or risk falling behind their competition.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: We see the need for automation technologies being centered around space, accuracy, labor, and throughput, which we often refer to as “S.A.L.T.” The largest factors are focused on the need to do more work in less space and increasing throughput in a more efficient way.

Q: HOW HAVE GEOPOLITICAL FACTORS LIKE TARIFFS AND RISING FUEL AND TRANSPORTATION COSTS AFFECTED YOUR BUSINESS AND THE COST PICTURE FOR YOUR CUSTOMERS?

Michael Walters – Swisslog: I think those factors have created more uncertainty around project pricing and timing, particularly for systems that rely on globally sourced components. While these pressures can increase the initial cost of automation, they rarely change the fundamental business case when the solution delivers strong operational value. In many cases, the same volatility is reinforcing the investment need for automation to create more resilient, predictable operations and reduce future exposure.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: The price of diesel is having a major impact on supply chain budgets. When 5% to 10% of your supply chain costs are related to fuel and fuel increases from $3.50 per gallon (January ’26) to over $6 (October ’26) in 10 months, companies often use dollars [that had been earmarked for] supply chain improvements and expansions to make up the difference.

Colin McAleenan – Hai: These events have an impact on ALL industries, not just warehouse automation investments. At the end of the day, we need to look at these types of events as pressure points on our supply chains and how we design our operations to work around disruptions to meet customer needs. As the saying goes, “Iron sharpens iron,” so we should be using these events, and the expectation of further challenges, to really examine our ability to deliver for our customers.

Q: WHAT IS THE COST OF NOT AUTOMATING?

Adam Cole – Storage Solutions: In the worst-case scenario, business continuity is the cost. In labor-constrained environments, companies literally cannot hire enough people, forcing them to either automate or scale back their business. Safety and morale are also big [considerations]. Automation is ergonomic and reduces the need for employees to work in harsh and unsafe conditions (a good example is automating away the need to enter a freezer to pull product).

In less-extreme scenarios, costs include reduced customer satisfaction and missed financial opportunities. Automation can help fulfill customer orders faster and more accurately, leading to a better customer experience. It can also reduce cost through [higher] efficiency and increase revenue through [higher] productivity.

Colin McAleenan – Hai: By not automating, I fear many warehouse operators will go the way of the dodo. There is comfort in continuing to operate in ways that are familiar and established. However, we know several things to be true looking ahead: There will be fewer humans in the workforce, that workforce will not want to work in manual warehouses, and they will want to be paid more. Manual operators should accept this reality and plan to get ahead of it.

People like working in environments where robotics and automation are a part of the operation. Postponing this investment will only further erode a manual operator’s ability to attract talent in a competitive industry.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: That’s simple: increased supply chain costs. The automation of today is having great impact on space utilization and throughput. Doing more with less. The side effects are increased accuracy and labor efficiency. When others are doing more with less and your supply chain isn’t evolving, you are left with sacrificing margin.

Oana Jinga – Dexory: The biggest cost is the risk of being left behind. Warehousing is moving toward an AI- and automation-first future, and businesses that fail to keep pace will find it increasingly difficult to meet expectations around speed, efficiency, and responsiveness. Without automation and access to continuous, accurate operational data, teams remain more reliant on manual processes and incomplete information, making it harder to identify issues quickly and adapt to changing demand. Increasingly, automation isn’t simply about reducing costs; it’s about building the agility and intelligence needed to remain competitive.

Michael Walters – Swisslog: The cost of inaction is often greater than the investment being deferred. In my experience, it shows up through rising fulfillment costs, declining productivity, and the need to add people and/or facilities just to support growth. There is also a significant opportunity cost in lost capacity, delayed growth, and market share ceded to competition with faster, more scalable operations.

Q: WHAT ONE PROBLEM DO CUSTOMERS MOST WISH TO SOLVE WITH ROBOTICS?

Colin McAleenan – Hai: Operational resiliency. Uncertainty is our new normal. Robotics should create the degree of flexibility, scale, and certainty that operators need to face whatever pivots their operation needs to make to address seasonality, surges, unexpected costs, rapid growth, and changing SLAs [service-level agreements].

Michael Walters – Swisslog: The straightforward answer is addressing labor unpredictability. The ability to maintain throughput and operational quality when staffing levels, turnover, and demand fluctuate is always top of mind. The most successful implementations don’t just focus on what is being solved, but rather the **ital{how:} How can we design an operation where people and technology each perform the work they are best suited to do? Historically, robotics solutions have been designed to handle repetitive, strenuous, or non-value-added tasks. However, as robotic functionality continues to advance, we are seeing increasingly complex applications become viable opportunities.

Adam Cole – Storage Solutions: The problems range from palletizing/depalletizing to picking/replenishment to transportation. It truly depends on the customer! That said, when people think of robots, they often think of an automated person. This is natural—our world was built for processes performed by people—but it is a mistake. It’s like that old saying, “Don’t pave the cow path.” A meandering path is great for a slow cow, but it would be terrible for a high-speed freeway. Likewise, don’t try to automate a manual process that was intentionally limited to the capabilities of a human. Design a process based on the capabilities of the automation technology.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: Labor. Managing labor has become increasingly difficult. Training, ergonomics, employee satisfaction, supervision, shift management, and illnesses and ailments all come with great indirect costs up and beyond the ever-increasing wages for a marketplace with high demand.

Oana Jinga – Dexory: For our customers, the fundamental challenge is gaining accurate, continuous visibility of what is happening across their operations. Warehouses are highly dynamic environments, yet many teams still rely on manual processes and fragmented data that provide only a snapshot of what’s happening at a given moment. Autonomous robotics can continuously capture data at scale, giving teams a much clearer, real-time understanding of their operations. Ultimately, the robot is the enabler. The real value comes from turning that data into actionable intelligence that helps teams identify issues faster, make better decisions, and continuously improve performance.

Q: WHAT ROLE DOES ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) PLAY IN THE DESIGN AND OPERATION OF YOUR AUTOMATED SYSTEMS?

Art Eldred – Attabotics: We see artificial intelligence progressing in three ways within the fulfillment operation. The first is automating and easing the serving of relevant information—training documentation, operational KPIs [key performance indicators], and event research to help understand why certain behaviors occurred.

Second is in making recommendations. AI is great at processing large amounts of information, deciphering their tracks and trends, and providing that information in a format that decision-makers can easily act upon.

Third and not that far away, we see a world where the AI decision engine can effectively and proactively make 600 or more decisions an hour—whereas our current human operations staff is likely capable of 15 decisions per hour—providing a whole new level of efficiency within the operational flow of a fulfillment operation.

Oana Jinga – Dexory: AI plays an increasingly important role in turning the huge volumes of data collected by autonomous systems into useful intelligence. At Dexory, combining robotics with AI gives warehouse teams a continuous understanding of what is happening across their operations, helping them identify discrepancies, uncover patterns, and surface issues that require attention. This shifts teams from manually searching for problems to proactively addressing them, enabling faster decision-making and more efficient operations.

Michael Walters – Swisslog: AI plays a major role in iteration pace on the data and ideation phase. Historically, significant time has been spent analyzing datasets and evaluating different concepts. AI enables a quicker, more data-driven design process and gives customers greater confidence that the proposed solution is aligned with their strategic objectives.

Operationally, AI is becoming increasingly important in areas such as machine vision and robotic piece picking, fleet orchestration and optimization, predictive maintenance, and operational analytics. I think a key impact will come from AI’s ability to transform real-time warehouse data into actionable insights.

Q: WHAT DO YOUR CUSTOMERS CONSIDER TO BE AN ACCEPTABLE RETURN ON INVESTMENT (ROI), AND DOES THAT VARY BY THE TYPE OF PROJECT?

Adam Cole – Storage Solutions: ROI acceptability varies by the specific circumstances of each customer. If a client is in a labor-constrained environment, business continuity, not ROI, will be the primary driver of investment decisions. If employees are being hurt or working in harsh environments, safety will be the main driver. That said, ROI is important, and payback typically happens in one to five years, with many projects paying themselves back in 12 to 36 months.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: When diesel prices surge as they [currently] are doing, acceptable ROI climbs rapidly. The typical three- to five-year ROI quickly changes to measurements in months.

Colin McAleenan – Hai: Assuming the only investment is the pick engine and that reserve storage and dock-door coordination is left to existing or manual means, a pick engine AS/RS [automated storage and retrieval system] investment should yield an ROI of three years or less. This target is why it is so important for operators to get their automation partners involved in this discussion early on. There may be “hidden” operational benefits that an automation partner sees that stare the operator in the face every day. Highlighting these additional benefits before asking for budget is a crucial step many operators skip, unfortunately.

Q: WHAT ARE THE BIGGEST MISTAKES COMPANIES MAKE IN CHOOSING AND IMPLEMENTING AUTOMATED EQUIPMENT?

Colin McAleenan – Hai: My experience has been that purchasers of automation equipment are prone to making three fatal mistakes: First, they don’t have their manual processes dialed in and try to automate imperfect processes. Exception handing is a great example—if the processes around exception handling are not well documented and you just address them ad hoc in the manual operation, how do you hope to [define them] and have automation [deliver on its promise to improve them]?

Secondly, tightly coupled to process excellence is data completeness and trust in the source(s) of truth. Good process control creates reliable data. Gaps in data lead to assumptions. Assumptions create risk when plugging them into solution designs. Good operators have control over their processes, which are measurable. Whatever you can measure, you can automate. Whatever you can automate, you can scale.

Third, don’t focus only on the process being automated while ignoring the upstream and downstream ramifications that a more efficient pick engine creates. You must consider these investments against the totality of impact they will have and plan accordingly.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: Rushing to a finish. Automation often crosses many teams. Having the right stakeholders in automation projects is critical for success. This often means operations, info security, information technology, strategy, finance, and others who need to be involved and work together on common goals and outcomes.

Adam Cole – Storage Solutions: The biggest mistake is installing a system not suited to their operations, which in the worst scenarios will do more harm than good. Buyers of automation are faced with a growing universe of options, and navigating it is challenging without a knowledgeable partner. Expert system providers will analyze a customer’s data to ensure they design and deliver a system customized to the client’s needs. What happens if there is little to no data? Expert providers are adept at collecting data and understanding business processes, business needs, and goals to design a tailored system that adds value.

Q: HOW CAN AUTOMATION HELP FACILITIES RIGHT-SIZE THEIR INVENTORIES?

Michael Walters – Swisslog: Visibility and predictability. I think many companies underestimate how much inventory is really a symptom of uncertainty. In manual operations, inventory records are only as good as the last transaction. When there is a lack of confidence in [data] accuracy, it is natural to compensate by carrying additional stock to protect service levels. Automation creates a real-time view of inventory across the operation, improving accuracy, traceability, and transparency. It helps in the shift from inventory buffers to information-driven decisions.

Colin McAleenan – Hai: Automation will help control the inventory accuracy, since it is held captive within the system and tightly orchestrated inbound/outbound movements are dictated by the upper-level software. The WES [warehouse execution system] really is responsible for producing accurate snapshots of what inventory is in the system and what is or isn’t moving against order history. The automation itself provides the confidence that the security of the items can produce a reliable report of the inventory at any given time.

Oana Jinga – Dexory: You cannot effectively optimize inventory without first having an accurate picture of what you have, where it is, and how it is changing. Automation provides that continuous visibility, creating a reliable data foundation that helps businesses identify discrepancies, understand how stock is moving, and make better use of available warehouse space. With more accurate operational data, teams can make better-informed decisions about stock levels and space utilization, helping them right-size inventory while improving the efficiency of the wider operation.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: Right-sizing inventories needs to start with the business. Many factors are involved in sizing inventories: supply chain disruptions, safety stocks, cycle times from manufacturing to destination, peak periods, business performance, etc. What automation can help with is making better use of an overall warehouse space and not simply the square footage of the floor. Various types of automation can go higher and denser and move faster, providing business with strong advantages.

Adam Cole – Storage Solutions: Automation results in inventory transparency. An automated storage system, for example, must know what it is storing in order to retrieve a specific item when requested. This creates transparency: Customers now know what they have and what is and isn’t moving. They can then take action to eliminate unneeded inventory.

Q: HOW CAN GAMIFICATION BE USED TO ENHANCE THE WORK ENVIRONMENT?

Colin McAleenan – Hai: Humans are inherently competitive. Finding fun ways to leverage the inner competitor can be done in a number of ways. I’ve seen creative shift-to-shift and team-to-team leaderboards. These can either exist out on the shop floor or in the break rooms.

Employee recognition and rewards systems that stem from data captured in the automation also improve employee perception of working with the equipment. I’ve seen employees promoted to team leads and trainers because their performance shone when viewed through the lens of automation reports. The insights you can gain from leveraging the reporting automation gives you can be used in a myriad of ways to tailor rewards and recognition programs based on company culture.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: Gamification can improve the work environment, but it has to be done right. The key is having accurate measurement points that lead to quantifiable results and incentives for the employees. This may prove challenging in the future with AI making many more decisions that may be counterproductive for the worker but good for the overall flow of a building.

Michael Walters – Swisslog: I think gamification has a real role to play as a younger, digitally native workforce enters our industry. They have grown up with instant feedback, progress tracking, and interactive technology. Bringing some of those concepts into the workplace can make training and daily work more engaging. Automation can create a stronger connection between employees and their work through skill development, achievement milestones, and visibility into performance.

Q: HOW DOES WORK CHANGE FOR EMPLOYEES WHEN FACILITIES MOVE FROM MANUAL PROCESSES TO AUTOMATED SYSTEMS?

Michael Walters – Swisslog: From my perspective, it alters where people create value. It gives employees an opportunity to develop stronger technical and problem-solving skills as their roles evolve alongside automation. Our work often involves people who have performed the same job for decades and carry a tremendous amount of tribal knowledge, so the transition can understandably feel daunting. Once employees [get over] that initial hurdle and experience how the automation technology improves their work, there is a boost to morale, engagement, and retention.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: The success of migrating from manual to automation starts with a well-thought-out change management process that touches every point that the automation influences. This can involve everything from educating the marketing team on constraints often associated with automation to the training and education of those who interface with automation on a daily basis. If done correctly, automation can prove to be a real morale improvement, increasing employee satisfaction. Automation is often misinterpreted as a job killer and not recognized [for its ability to make] workers’ jobs more enjoyable and efficient.

Adam Cole – Storage Solutions: It gets better. Ergonomics improve, the work environment improves, and effort decreases while productivity increases. In other words, employees are safer, more comfortable, more productive, and less tired.

Oana Jinga – Dexory: Automation should remove repetitive, time-consuming work rather than simply replacing people. By automating tasks such as manually scanning locations, collecting data, or searching for issues, it frees employees to spend more time investigating exceptions, resolving problems, and improving operations. It shifts human effort toward higher-value tasks where judgement, experience, and decision-making have the greatest impact.

Colin McAleenan – Hai: Overall, it can be dramatic if change management is not treated as its own swim lane in the project schedule. Leadership needs to sponsor and drive the incremental, yet continuous, messaging that happens alongside projects like these. Bringing all facets of the organization along for the journey is crucial. The best transitions I have seen involve regular townhall updates, pre-launch workshops, go-live support, and leveraging the insights data gives you to tweak the operation as you ramp up. The most damaging transitions happen when champions leave, leadership changeover occurs, or messaging gets lost, and worst of all, when operators continue to run their newly automated warehouse like a manual one.

Q: WHAT’S THE NEXT BIG ADVANCEMENT WE WILL SEE IN ROBOTICS?

Oana Jinga – Dexory: The next major advancement will be bringing together robotics, AI, and real-world operational data so that AI can better understand and respond to physical environments. Rather than robots simply performing a single automated task, they will increasingly act as a bridge between the physical and digital worlds, continuously capturing data that AI can interpret to identify issues, uncover patterns, and anticipate where attention is needed. In warehouses, this will make robotics not just a tool for automation, but also a critical source of operational intelligence and better decision-making.

Colin McAleenan – Hai: Physical AI in general is fascinating. As we continue to evaluate existing, fixed-point solutions against mobile, embodied AI solutions, one element that keeps my wheels spinning is the concept of the world model. A world model is an AI system that learns how the physical world works, how objects and environments behave, and how those environments will change in response to actions taken by a robot. The laws of physics are universal and objectively measurable. Decisions about how to behave within those laws are not.

A robot may be at risk of incomplete observations, imperfect sensors, or limited onboard computation—limiting its abilities to act in accordance with how we think it should. Two different world models may therefore make different predictions without either being fundamentally irrational. Ultimately, I think we get a model that blends a universal foundation with several specialized systems built on top of it. I am genuinely excited to see what applications ultimately lead us to that conclusion.

Michael Walters – Swisslog: I think the evolution of Physical AI will continue to be the main advancement. Improvement of situational flexibility and operational robustness through digital intelligence will remain a focus in the industry. Rather than simply surfacing information for managers to act on, these systems will increasingly take proactive actions on their own, re-optimizing workflows, adjusting priorities, and responding to disruptions in real time. Just as importantly, they will provide a clear audit trail of what actions were taken, why they were taken, and the expected operational impact.

Art Eldred – Attabotics: The largest advancement will be in the number of tasks a single robot can accomplish and the speed at which it can perform them. Today we have a large array of robots that store and retrieve products or aid in transportation and interface with inventory. Adding autonomous picking functions and [capabilities] such as taping boxes, applying labels, and cutting open cartons of product to a single robot really are next generation at this point [and are] not that far off.



Source link

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.