Fresno City Hall sues Arts Council over embezzlement

0 27


Months after a public embezzlement scandal rocked Fresno’s growing arts community, City Hall is suing the Fresno Arts Council “to hold the organization legally and financially accountable for the catastrophic loss of over $1.8 million in voter-approved Measure P tax dollars.”

A spokesperson for the city attorney’s office said the lawsuit was filed Wednesday in Fresno County Superior Court.

In a statement Thursday, City Attorney Andrew Janz said the Arts Council and its board of directors failed to exercise “basic fiduciary oversight” and violated its contract with City Hall when the organization’s ex-operations manager, Suliana Caldwell, stole more than $1.8 million, which she spent on vacations and gambling.

Caldwell, 46, pleaded guilty in connection with the case and was sentenced to nearly three years in federal prison earlier this year.

“Sending one employee to federal prison does not let the Fresno Arts Council off the hook for its gross negligence and breach of contract,” said Fresno City Attorney Andrew Janz in the news release. “We are taking them to court to aggressively claw back every single dollar stolen from Fresno taxpayers.”

Janz said City Hall is seeking full restitution.

In a statement late Thursday, attorneys for the Arts Council board fired back, calling the lawsuit meritless and positioned themselves as the true victims in the case.

“The money that was stolen was not stolen from the City of Fresno,” the council lawyers said in a statement. “It was stolen from the Fresno Arts Council.”

The Arts Council’s statement also says it was the City of Fresno’s responsibility to conduct annual independent audits, which they say didn’t happen.

“The City of Fresno is blaming the Fresno Arts Council and the community members who volunteered to serve on its Board, for the City’s own failure to conduct adequate oversight,” attorneys for the council said.

“We are disappointed that the City of Fresno decided to sue volunteer community members for its own failures,” council lawyers added. “Our clients intend to vigorously defend themselves against this meritless lawsuit.”

The lawsuit names as defendants the Arts Council and Caldwell. It also singles out the organization’s former executive director under whom the alleged embezzlement came to light, Lilia Gonzáles-Chávez, and several current and former board members, including its current Board President Olga Gutierrez De Nuñez.

During Caldwell’s federal prosecution it was revealed that Caldwell funneled the money from Arts Council bank accounts via PayPal — across more than 300 transactions. In federal court filings, prosecutors said PayPal had reimbursed the Arts Council at least  $901,884.83.

In the complaint filed this week, Fresno claims the Arts Council has been sitting on that money and has not returned it to City Hall.

City officials have said they were forced to pull money from other sources to adequately fund the Measure P arts work.

“These taxpayer funds could have been spent on additional police and fire services, and on maintaining the City’s parks and roads,” city officials said in the complaint. “The arts community in the City was damaged, as it relied on the Measure P funds and made business plans expecting to timely receive Measure P funds.”

In the lawsuit filed this week, city leaders also claim the Arts Council told them in late September of 2024 that no Measure P arts funding had been distributed at that point. They say the Arts Council provided finance statements backing those claims.

Now, the city says they don’t believe that was true and specifically, the lawsuit says, the Arts Council distributed Measure P funds between Sept. 12 and Oct. 29 of 2024.

It’s not clear in the lawsuit when city leaders began doubting the council’s representations about the fall 2024 funding cycle.

But, the city sent the council another $5.7-plus million on Oct. 1 that same year to distribute. 

The lawsuit also raises questions about Caldwell’s qualifications, claiming that, before she was hired by the Arts Council in 2021, she had been working as a truck driver and didn’t have a college degree.



Source link

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.